An agency founder told me about the salespeople their firm had hired.
"We've failed through two different salespeople, and including myself trying," they said.
I hear some version of that a lot. It usually comes up about ten minutes into a call, right after the founder tells me they're the bottleneck. So this fall I wanted to know how common it really is. In October I surveyed 55 independent agency leaders about where their new business comes from and who it depends on.
25 of them had hired a first salesperson. One of those hires is still there and hitting goals.
One out of 25 is 4%. And it's the number I keep coming back to in this year's agency new business report, The Hardest Job to Hand Off. It's free, and you don't need to give me your email to read it.
Now, if you run a SaaS startup, most of the first-sales-hire advice out there was written for you, and this post won't add much. I'm writing for the owner of an agency that grew on referrals and the founder's name.
I'm also writing it because that 4% is going to sting, and I don't want anyone to read it as "never hire a salesperson." The data says something about the order you do things in.
What happened to the 25 first sales hires
I asked every agency that made the hire how it turned out. Here's how the 25 answered:
36% said the person left or was let go within 12 months.
36% said the person left or was let go after 12 months.
20% still have the person, but below goals.
4% said it was too early to tell.
4% said the person is still there and hitting goals.
"Still with us and hitting goals" was the very first option on the list. One agency picked it.
I know 25 agencies is a small group, so I wouldn't lean too hard on the exact figure. But a second survey I ran this year, the 2026 Agency Sales Maturity Benchmark, points the same way. That one asked a different group of 23 agencies, and 83% of their sales hires were gone.
And the salary isn't the only cost. At 52% of the agencies that made a sales hire, the founder still closes new deals today. So you pay for the hire, and you end up back on every sales call anyway.
Another founder gave me the whole story in two sentences: "We had a salesperson working for us about six years ago. They just couldn't find enough work to justify their salary."
I've written before about why first agency sales hires fail. This survey puts a count on it.
Why the first agency sales hire fails: nobody wrote the selling down
Most of the time the person isn't the problem. The salesperson walks into a firm where exactly one person knows how to sell, and almost none of it is on paper.
The data shows how normal that is. At 71% of the agencies in the survey, the founder closes new deals. At 62%, nobody but the founders is responsible for bringing in new business at all.
Dan Englander, the founder of Sales Schema, put it well on my podcast: "The agency ends up asking a salesperson to invent the system for getting revenue, which is an extremely entrepreneurial task."
A founder described the same thing from the other side of the desk. "Every time we try to work with a biz dev person they're always like, just tell us the one thing you do and we can go sell it, and we don't."
So the salesperson asks for the playbook. And there isn't one yet, because it still lives in the founder's head.
The sales hire has company, too. 85% of the agencies have tried at least one of the seven fixes I asked about, and most of those fixes let them down. Here's the share of firms that tried each one and said it disappointed:
Cold email or calling: 79%
Paid ads: 69%
Outsourced lead generation: 68%
A first sales hire: 68%
I read those as the same problem showing up four times. Each fix gets bought to do a job that, so far, only the founder knows how to do.
The report has a short rule for this: paper before people. Write down how you sell before you pay someone else to do it. I go deeper on the cause in my post on founder dependency.
Where agency new business comes from when the fixes don't hold
When the hire and the ads don't work out, new business falls right back on the founder.
Last year, 80% of the agencies won a client through the founders' own network. Paid ads brought in a client at 4%.
More than half of them (58%) get most of their new clients from referrals or that network. And to be fair, referrals are good clients. They close faster and they show up already trusting you.
The trouble is that nobody at the agency decides when the next one shows up. That makes it really hard to plan a year, and 71% of the agencies have been through a year or more of flat or falling revenue.
You'd think getting bigger would fix it. It helps less than you'd expect. The founder closes new deals at 91% of agencies under $1M, and still at 68% of agencies between $1M and $3M. It only drops to 38% at $3M and up.
So passing $1M doesn't move the selling off the founder by itself. If that's where you are, my post on building a pipeline without founder-led selling covers what to build next to referrals.
The full agency new business report breaks every finding out by firm size, so you can see how your agency compares to firms like yours.
What the agencies that hold steady do differently
Some agencies have moved the selling off the founder. I asked everyone what would happen to new deals if the founders stepped out of sales for 90 days, and 22% said deals would stay about the same.
Those firms look different in two ways. At 92% of them, someone other than the founders is responsible for new business. At 83%, someone else closes the deals.
Size doesn't explain it. A quarter of those firms are under $1M.
Pricing seems to travel with it. At 60% of the agencies, someone other than the founders can quote a typical project. Where nobody else can quote, the founder closes at 91% of firms. Where someone else can, it's 58%.
Now, the survey can't tell me which came first. But it points to an order of work, and the hire comes last:
Record your next few sales calls and write down what you ask, and in what order.
Write down how you priced your last three projects.
Give new business one owner and one number, like first calls booked each month.
Then hire the salesperson, and train them yourself. Stay in the room for their first few calls.
I'll be honest about the cost. This is slower than posting a job. Writing down how you sell takes a few months of your time, and when you're the one who's good at selling, it can feel like busywork. But it's the one part a new hire can't do for you.
Curious where your agency stands? Hand your next proposal to someone on your team and ask them to price it. If they can't do it without coming back to you, start with step two.
An agency that wins new business when you're not in the room
About half of the founders in the survey (49%) plan to step back within three years. That count includes the ones who plan to sell and the ones bringing in a successor.
At 70% of those agencies, the founder still closes the deals. And a plan to step back gets a lot harder if the new clients leave with you.
One founder told me what they want instead. "I'm trying to get to the point where new work comes in a certain cadence, even if it's one or two clients a year, that's not directly dependent on me having to do something."
That's really what the whole report is about: an agency that keeps winning clients when you take a month off.
If you want to see how your agency compares, read The Hardest Job to Hand Off. It's free, and every finding comes with one thing to try.
If you'd like a read on your own firm first, get your Bottleneck Score. It's a free diagnostic of 18 questions, and it shows where your new business depends on you the most.
And when you're ready to fix what the score finds, the New-Business Engine is how I work with agencies at Haus Advisors. I draft the strategy and the first versions, and your team builds them and runs them.
